Common Questions About Costs of Attorney and Expert Retention in Michigan Eminent Domain Cases 

Is there a cost to retain counsel? 

Generally, no. I typically provide representation on a contingent fee basis and do not charge a retainer as part of the engagement process. 

How does the contingent fee work? 

Under MCL 213.55(1), an agency using the power of eminent domain must issue a good faith written offer (“GFO”). The three most pertinent requirements of a GFO include identification of the just compensation being offered, a survey identifying the area being taken, and definitive contractual language identifying property rights being acquired by the agency and the right to remaining with the owner (often an easement). The contingent fee is based upon a GFO. I charge 1/3 of the increased just compensation and interest above the GFO. Therefore, if an agency were to offer $2 then I would robtain a resolution of $5, the increase would be $3 ($5 - $2 = $3) and the attorney fee would be $1 (1/3 x $3  = $1). 

Does the agency reimburse the 1/3 attorney fee that owner can keep the full just compensation? 

Typically, yes. While past results are not a promise for future performance, in hundreds of Michigan cases that I have handled, the agency has fully reimbursed the contingent attorney-fee without controversy. 

Are there legal arguments that an agency could make to avoid reimbursing the standard contingent fee? 

While it has been extremely rare, yes.   

First, MCL 213.66(2) requires the agency to pay a reasonable fee up to 1/3 of the increased just compensation and interest. An agency could challenge whether the contingent was reasonable. However, the last instance that I experienced in which an agency made such a challenge occurred in the late 1990s. At that time, the Michigan Department of Transportation commonly challenged reimbursement of the 1/3 contingency fee in cases where it had made such exceptionally lowball offers that the contingent fees resulted in extremely high hourly rates. MDOT lost virtually all these challenges and I cannot recall a single instance of the agency challenging whether the reasonability of the standard 1/3 contingency. 

In addition, MCL 213.55(3) created a process by which owners must identify certain items that were excluded from the GFO. If the agency agrees that it had improperly or unwittingly excluded an item, it may agree to pay it and avoid reimbursing the contingent fee. That statutory process was implemented in 2006. I cannot recall a single instance in which an agency has updated an offer to avoid paying the contingent attorney fee.   

In the hundreds of cases that I have handled against public agencies like the Michigan Department of Transportation, drain commissions, road commissions, or private agencies including utility companies, I can only recall one instance in which the contingent fee was not fully reimbursed, that occurred in the 1990s, and occurred because the property owner who had not yet hired an attorney made statements relied upon by the agency (which is one of the reasons that early retention of counsel is important). 

Are there instances in which you charge an hourly fee? 

Yes, there are limited times when clients request that I provide additional services on an hourly basis. These circumstances generally occur when the property owners request that I negotiate to minimize the impacts of the taking. While I am happy to do so to accomplish my client’s goals, I cannot perform those services as part of a contingent relationship. I would be effectively doing more work to earn a smaller fee, since an agency’s agreement to minimize the impact of the taking reduces the just compensation that it must pay. 

Some examples of these situations include cooperating with the agency to obtain a variance minimizing zoning impacts pursuant to MCL 213.54 or renegotiating either the contractual terms or area encumbered by easements. 

Are property owners entitled to reimbursement of expert expenses? 

Yes. MCL 213.66(3) requires agencies to reimburse expert expenses.  Essentially, property owners in Michigan are entitled to their own, independent, expert evaluation of just compensation issues.  Similar to the reimbursement of attorney fees, an agency could assert that the expert fees were unreasonable. Yet, while past results are not a promise of future performance, this virtually never occurs. In hundreds of cases, agencies have voluntarily reimbursed all expert expenses without controversy.     

Are other types of litigation expenses reimbursable? 

Potentially, yes. The reimbursement of these types of expenses often comes down to a negotiation. They are often fully reimbursed. In some instances, owners are satisfied with settlements and forego some limited reimbursement. Often, these expenses are not material in the context of the larger negotiation. 

Must I pay these expenses out of pocket? 

Typically, no. The agency is required to pay the estimate of just compensation contained in GFO at the outset of a case. In the vast majority of situations, this is sufficient to fund the litigation without the clients fronting any funds. The property owners then obtain reimbursement at the conclusion. I make a good faith estimate of the amount that I believe is necessary to pay litigation costs and distribute any balance to the property owner. 

Next
Next

Common Issues Considered When Seeking More Just Compensation Resulting from a Utility Easement Taking